Tuesday 24 September 2013

SHIAS BELIEVE IN THE CORRUPTION OF QURAN (TAHREEF) VIA MORE THAN 1022 NARRATION IN THEIR BOOKS

NOTE: THE TOPIC OF TAHREEF ( Quranic corruption, alteration) IS NOT ONLY FAMOUS AMONG NON MUSLIMS  BUT THIS IS ALSO ONE OF THE CORE FUNDAMENTALS OF SHI`A AQEEDAH AND THEIR DEEN. THERE ARE 1000 PAGES OR EVEN MORE CONTENT OF REFUTATION FILLED WITH PROVES AGAINST THEM ON THIS TOPIC BUT I SHALL ONLY PRESENT A SHORT SUMMARY FOR THE COMMON READER.


Alee, may Allah be pleased with him, said: "Whoever disbelieves in a letter from it (the Qur`an), so surely he disbelieved in all of it"
[Ref: It came out of ‘Abd ar-Razzaaq (8/472, number 15946). And at-Tabaree transmitted it in the introduction to his ‘Tafseer’ 1/54, from ‘Ibn ‘Aleeyah from Shu’ayb. And indeed ‘Abd Allah bin al-Mubaarak said its equal (Majmuu’ al-Fataaawaa: 4/182). And indeed ‘Ibn ‘Uthaymeen said its equal in (Majmuu’ Fataawaa 5/23) from ‘Alee, may Allah have mercy on him. And indeed ‘Ibn Hajar said its equal in ‘al-Mutaalib al-’Aaleeyah’: the chapter of Belief and Warning (5/339) from ‘Abd Allah bin Mas’ood.]

Would you ever Imagine Abu Haneefah (r.h) or any other Imaam of the Muslim claiming that the Qur`an is corrupted? Distorted?  `Aaudhubillahi min ar-Rafidhir-Rajeem (I seek protection in Allah from the accursed rafidhi)



The way of the Shia is to cling to any random weak narration in the Books of Sunnis and make it an undisputed historical fact if it happens to agree with their beliefs and if it supports their case against the companions of the Prophet (s.a.w). However, if a narration is quoted against them, you will see them researching and citing sources and studying the authenticity and the text and trying to give various interpretations in order to defend their Madhab.

Their scholar Murtada al-`Askari is no different than all his other companions when it comes to hypocrisy, this man wanted to defend the Shia religion because they were being accused of believing in the corruption of the Qur’an. Their books are fully loaded with narrations about how the Qur’an was altered and changed by the companions of the Prophet (s.a.w), and how the virtues of Ahlul-Bayt were deleted from it and such…

Shia scholar al-`Allamah Muhammad Salih al-Mazindarani says in “Sharh al-Kafi” 11/76:

[The deletion of some parts of the Qur'an and its corruption was established in our sources with Tawatur (i.e reported down by so many numerous routes and chains that it is impossible this could have been a lie) , as it is apparent for those who observe the books of Hadith from beginning to end.]

Shia scholar Sultan Muhammad al-Janabidhi says in “Tafsir Bayan al-Sa`adah fi Maqamat al-`Ibadah” pg.19:

[Know (O reader) that a plentiful amount of narrations from the pure Imams state that additions and deletions and corruption and change have taken place in it, in a way that leaves no doubt.]

Shia scholar Muhammad al-Lucknawi wrote in “Darbat Haydari” 2/78:

[The claim that no corruption took place in the Qur'an is apparently corrupt, because the narrations showing this corruption have reached Tawatur.]

Shia scholar `Abdullah Shubbar said in “Masabih al-Anwar fi Hall Mushkilat al-Akhbar” 2/294-295:

[Most of what is in our hands today is the Qur'an that was revealed upon the Prophet (as) and many parts of it have been removed, as proven by the great amount of narrations that are almost Mutawatir, and we have clarified this in our book: Muniyah al-Muhasileen fi Haqiyat Tareeq al-Mujtahideen.]

Shia scholar Muhammad Mahdi al-Naraqi said in “Minhaj al-Ahkam” under the chapter “Hujjiyat Zawahir al-Kitab”:

[Deletion has taken place in the Qur'an, meaning: Parts of it have been removed, even if we do not know specifically where it is, as shown by the many un-contradicted narrations and proofs.]

The Shia belief that narrations reaching Tawatur from the Imams state that the Qur’an was corrupted, this belief has been reported by many Shia scholars that we cannot mention now so that we do not go off-topic, one of their scholars called al-Noori al-Tabrasi has collected a huge amount of these narrations, their scholar Muhammad Hadi Ma`rifah wrote in “Siyanat al-Qur’an” pg.239:

[What al-Noori had collected from narrations of corruption, are more than a thousand and one hundred (1122) to be exact.]

Now we return to Murtada al-`Askari who wanted to defend his Madhab from the accusation of corruption, wrote a three volume set called “al-Qur’an wa Riwayat al-Madrasatayn”, in the third volume which is 847 pages, he went through 1062 narrations of corruption and rejected all of them, by weakening their chain of transmission or by giving them a suitable interpretation, he then said at the end of his book:

[al-Sheikh al-Noori and Ihsan Ilahi Zaheer have quoted 1062 narrations which they claimed prove the corruption of the Qur'an, and by the favor of Allah we have studied them one by one, their chains and their texts, and we found that all of them share one of two things:

Either their chains contain extremists or liars or unknown or weak narrators, or the text is only an explanation for the verse as opposed to their claim that it was erased from it, and at many times both.]

And finally he declares on page 874, that all those narrations are “zero” and they amount to nothing at all!

I say: First of all, if this hypocrite were to apply his methods of weakening narrations, to all the Shia books of Hadith, then their entire library of books would become one big zero, not one narration would be left!


Some Videos that will SHOCK YOU OUT IF YOU AREN'T A STUDENT OF KNOWLEDGE ON SHI`ISM.


VIDEO ONE - WILL SURPRISE AND DISGUST YOU



Link : http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=TP-R6M5giVI#! VIDEO 2
Link : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olIX3zc7dWU

6 comments:

  1. no....you are in wrong....I'm shia and no body of us bleave that....Quran is correct.please Don't tzlk about sth that you aren't sure.........we bleave to God...Quran....profits and Imams......pls don't corrupt you'r here after.....Don't joge without enough informaition.....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Are you a Rafadite mohsen? Alawite? Cuz not all shia's have the same beliefs like in the 12 Imaams, and their infallability...

      As salaamu alaikum

      Delete
    2. Salam o alaikom,

      I am also a Shia (12 imams or Jafari) and in our sect we believe that there is only one Quran and nobody could corrupt it as also God mentioned it in Quran about its protection in surah Al-Hijr ayeh 9:

      "we have, without doubt, sent down the message; and we will assuredly guard it (from corruption)."

      So if a person is a Muslim and does not believe in Quran means denies this ayeh, so you cant call them Muslim. And since all of shia believe in Quran and this ayeh is part of it, you cannot have such a claim against shia.

      Another point is as you may know all of 4 sunni imams (imam hanaf, imam malek, imam shafe, and imam hanbal [alaihem o salam]) were the students of Imam Jafar e Sadiq (alaihe salam), so based on this there is not much difference between shariat law of Sunni and Shia. For example, a shia can pray behind a sunni imam and I myself do.
      So, instead of trying to make division in Islam, lets stay brothers and keep to the Habl o Allah and get united.
      As salamu alaikum.

      Delete
    3. Akhi Mohsen, the problem is that we don't know if what you are speaking right now is true or taqiyah. As taqiyah is a part of shi`a emaan said by all your Imaams.

      so it's very difficult for us. Nevertheless, if you say as you say , what we would reply is your personal observation or rulings are actually Zero in comparison to the rulings and fataawa of your scholars and your predeccesors. we cannot change our opinion of Hinduism based on what some random Hindu says. Likewise for Islam. Likewise for everything, So if your belief is as you say then Alhumdulillah you don't believe in tahreef.

      Delete
  2. Shia has never said Quran is destroyed by Sahabbas. this is whether a white lie or you are a mindless Wahabi

    ReplyDelete

To contact us, Please do so from the "Contact us" tab on the top of this page